You would not win, just as Dawkins cannot win from a creationist (see Youtube video of him with Wendy Wright). What does happen is that the creationist makes him/herself look ridiculous. In the case of Tony - just by his talk he has already made himself ridiculous - talking about wrong ties, tight pants, being homophobic, visiting Disney and more.
A true Christian leader would be talking about matters as cultivating the fruit of the spirit and Displaying Christlike Compassion - but such material is no longer taught by the witnesses. Even Jesus account of "he without sin cast the first stone" has been removed from their new "silver sword" Bible.
CULT!